 |
| Image credit: Wikipedia.org |
The cinematic climate in which we currently live is rife
with remakes. While I am primarily of the opinion that there is a wealth of
unexplored stories out there that could benefit from a screen adaptation, I am
also inclined to believe that there is absolutely nothing wrong with a remake,
as long as it’s done well. Doing a remake could arguably be as much of a gamble
as adapting a heretofore unadapted novel, the pressure lies with the director,
writer and everyone on the film’s credit list… and hinges on what is chosen to
be updated.
Comedy, as a genre, is a tricky playing field, as what is
considered funny today could well be downright offensive tomorrow. It’s the
fastest-changing genre of cinema as well as the truest supportive evidence that
art imitates life, so making the choice to remake a comedy is ballsy and tactical.
We’ve seen a number of reasonably successful comedies remade: Fun With Dick
and Jane (2005), Ghostbusters (2016), The Naked Gun (2025)
etc; all chosen because the stories lend themselves to a brand of comedy that
has managed to remain popular. Recently sprouted to add to this lush forest of
comedy remakes is The Roses, an updated version of the dark comedy War
of the Roses (1989) which starred Micheal Douglas and Kathleen Turner.
When architect Theo Rose (Benedict Cumberbatch) met chef Ivy
(Olivia Coleman), it was love at first sight. A raucous trip to the restaurant cool
room quickly escalated into a ten-year marriage in which Ivy takes care of the
kids and cooks part-time in her restaurant while Theo designs a historic museum
building. When a hurricane destroys the museum, Theo’s career is ruined, while
Ivy’s takes off as her struggling restaurant serves as a storm-escape for a
popular food critic. Suddenly, the roles are reversed with Ivy working
full-time and Theo looking after the kids. But as Ivy’s career as a popular
chef and restaurateur takes off, jealousy and resentment between her and Theo
starts to bubble to the surface and soon the two are locked in a vicious divorce,
trying to drive the other out of their dream house.
I did not realise that this was a remake when I settled down
for an afternoon with Disney+. I am inclined to now check out the original
because while I did enjoy this movie, I can’t really identify how I feel about
it and would like to see if the original differs or fills I any little craters
that The Roses was pitted with.
For the majority, the film is a delightfully modern, dark, and
witty verbal jousting match between the two romantic leads. Cumberbatch begins
the film as an ethical and idealistic gentleman whose inflated ego then takes a
battering and inspires him to push other people to achieve their potential. Coleman
is a charming and eloquently crass British take on the manic pixie dream girl
who then becomes the classic displaced, sardonic mother figure. The two are delightful
together, matching each other’s energy and delivering a very eloquent and
darkly funny script with mesmerising, scathing finesse. It’s like watching a
boxing match or fencing tourney in slow-motion; a compilation of when all the
best and brutal blows are landed that is disturbing, yet you can’t tear your
eyes away from it.
 |
| Image credit: Mubi |
I think the film falls down during the third act where the
all-out war breaks. The theatrical trailer shows all the best bits of the
insane battle that ensues. Audiences hoping for even more vicious and absurd
shenanigans are surprised during the height of the third act where the drama of
the entire film explosively rushes to the surface. We are aggressively shoved
into an anxious spiral of lost hope for a happy ending or any sort of closure. And
then the film ends on a shock-gasp shot that provides the perfect mental space
for the underlying depressing aspects of the movie – and indeed life and nature
of relationships - to cover our brains like a weighted blanket. The credits
roll on a mellow cover of ‘Happy Together’ that suddenly seems really dark,
while we stare unblinkingly at the screen, having mentally blue-screened.
While The Roses leaves a lasting impression, I feel
that the ending counteracts the hopeful threat of a happy ending throughout the
film and perhaps it would have had more of a profound impact if the film had
been marketed more as a drama with some comedic elements. Funnily, it reminded
me of Remember Me.
But, aside from the bombshell ending that tears everything
asunder, The Roses is a fun and entertaining look at the transformative
intricacies of modern relationships, the dangers of career-addiction, and the
romance of finding that someone who will have an EpiPen handy when you go into
anaphylactic shock.
Director: Jay Roach, 2025
Cast: Benedict Cumberbatch, Olivia Colmen, Andy Samberg,
Kate McKinnon, Ncuti Gatwa, Sunita Mani, Zoe Chao, Jamie Demetriou &
Allison Janney